
What makes a community actually work over time?
Is it the people or the systems? It's a question most communities never ask, until something goes wrong.
When most of us think about how a residential community governs itself, we tend to picture a version of the same thing: an elected board, a set of rules, a majority vote. Like an HOA (home owners’ association) or co-op board. The idea behind these structures is on the surface a good one. Residents elect people who have the time and skill, and want to represent the community. They're given a mandate and let them make decisions on everyone’s behalf on the assumption they will be making decisions in the community's best interests.
But in practice, what tends to happen is that the people willing to take on those roles are not always representative of the whole. In moments of pressure, decisions get made impatiently, in rooms that not everyone feels welcome in. When things get complicated (a conflict between neighbors, a costly repair, a disagreement about how shared spaces should be used), the process often defaults to whoever speaks with the most confidence or has held the role the longest.
Power structures develop, and resentments and division grow. The people who voice alternatives are often dismissed because it will take too long to analyze and incorporate, and, they eventually stop showing up.
But the issue isn’t generally the people; it’s the structure. These often thankless, unpaid positions lead to a top-down, majority-rules system that eventually produces the same results: a few people making decisions for everyone else, divisiveness, and everyone else gradually disengaging. The more power that’s concentrated at the top, the more this vicious cycle continues.
As we’re creating Alluma - Regenerative Communities, I knew the community would need a different structure that would be better in practice, for real people with real differences trying to share a life together.
There are communities out there that are deeply regenerative, beautifully health-focused, or genuinely community-centered. But very few have thought carefully about the systems that hold all of that together. This is what I believe makes Alluma different, and it starts with how we govern.
Stay tuned for the next post where I get into the governance model we chose and why it changes everything.
First published on Linkedin